Symphony Atlas

The Unanswered Question

19085 min

This guide follows Ives’s The Unanswered Question (1908) in one part.

Recording: hr-Sinfonieorchester, Andrés Orozco-Estrada (2018)

Premium

Follow all 8 sections as they play, free for 3 days

0:14–5:40

The strings begin alone with slow, soft chords, to a G major triad, and they never change pace. The trumpet then asks its five-note question, seven times (Question 1 to Question 7). The flutes the first six, each reply faster and more dissonant than the last, speeding from to until they give up. After the seventh question nothing answers, and the strings fade away.

  1. Question 1

Section boundaries in music are not always sharp; a transition may be felt over a pause or a held chord.

Report a timing error

In listening paths

See all →

Path 27

20th-century classical music

Twelve directions the century took, from Schoenberg's Verklärte Nacht of 1899 to Piazzolla's tango of 1982.

Schoenberg → Ives → Bartók → Holst → Gershwin → Barber → Prokofiev → Copland → Ligeti → Górecki → Piazzolla

12 works · 4 h 13 min

In the catalog

Charles Edward IvesOrchestral worksModern period

Join Symphony Atlas

Continue with GoogleCreate account

Have one? Sign in